the guy having a heart attack by the mcdonalds with nazi tattoos is a nazi. not the same as literal hitler. still an inhuman piece of shit. still worthless. still required to provide care. not the target of a worldwide multinational military operation requiring millions of russians to take berlin.
I don’t think so. If you do not retain the right to refuse service you must save Hitlers life. Given that the logic leads us to this ultimatum u must choose save Hitlers life ur retain the right to refuse service based on personal moral views.
Yes that’s the point. U cannot hold any 2 beliefs without running into at least one contradiction. Do u compromise on one belief or do u continue living pracricing literal doublethink.
and absurd
All hypotheticals are, that’s why they are a hypothetical
, so no.
I guess u have chosen doublethink. I wouldn’t want to be on the side of the absolute authoritarian big brother but that’s just me I guess.
the right to refuse providing life saving service to someone? even if I consider the person no longer a human because they chose to become a nazi?
not an actual right. if you can’t provide it, to everyone, even people who disgust you, you’re in the wrong industry.
Interesting so you would feel obligated to save Hitlers life from an injury that would be fatal without ur intervention?
reductio ad absurdum.
the guy having a heart attack by the mcdonalds with nazi tattoos is a nazi. not the same as literal hitler. still an inhuman piece of shit. still worthless. still required to provide care. not the target of a worldwide multinational military operation requiring millions of russians to take berlin.
I don’t think so. If you do not retain the right to refuse service you must save Hitlers life. Given that the logic leads us to this ultimatum u must choose save Hitlers life ur retain the right to refuse service based on personal moral views.
well then, you’re fucking wrong.
also “save life” different than “attempt”
Answer the ultimatum. That’s all I ask.
your ultimatum was impossible to answer and absurd, so no.
Yes that’s the point. U cannot hold any 2 beliefs without running into at least one contradiction. Do u compromise on one belief or do u continue living pracricing literal doublethink.
All hypotheticals are, that’s why they are a hypothetical
I guess u have chosen doublethink. I wouldn’t want to be on the side of the absolute authoritarian big brother but that’s just me I guess.
no no. the impossible part is that he’s already dead. you cannot be presented with your example.